I love Chick-Fil-A. For a lot of reasons. First, I think there food is just really good and there are so many good things on the menu. A few years ago I had a bad experience the first time that I tried Popeye's (which is right by our house) and have never wanted to go back. A couple years ago Popeye's introduced their Spicy Chicken Sandwich and it was all the rage, but I was just not interested. Finally, some co-workers who really love Popeye's convinced me that I needed to at least try it. So Shantel and I finally got a couple of sandwiches to try. Shantel loved it! I really liked it, but was not on board with putting it in the same class as Chick-Fil-a spicy chicken. This kicked us off into a month long Spicy Chicken Sandwich taste off.
Us with our Popeye's spicy chicken sandwich.
When Jenna was staying with us we decided to do a full on test comparison, including fries. This was a determination:
Best Customer Service (4 points): Chick-Fil-A. CFA won this by a mile. CFA employees are so friendly and make you feel good just for coming by. In addition, they are so fast. Even if the line is a mile long, you get through it just as fast as a short line at Popeye's. Popeye's employees sound like they don't really want to be there.
Best Bun (3 points): Popeye's wins this with a fluffier and overall better testing bun.
Best Value (4 points): At $3.99 Popeye's is less than the $4.29 for CFA. In addition, the bun and chicken are both bigger, so Popeye's wins for value if you just want the most food for least money.
Best Fries (2 points): CFA wins here. Popeye's has some cajun fries that look good. But in the end they did not taste better than the CFA waffle fries which were perfectly salted. In addition, the Popeye's fries were soggy and even when we tried heating them in the oven, did not get much better. CFA waffle fries stayed warmer and crispier and longer and had the better taste.
Mac and Cheese (1 point): Popeye's does not have Mac and Cheese, and Chick-Fil-a has delicious mac and cheese, so they win this one.
Chicken (5 points): CFA wins this as the Popeye's chicken is a bit dry and CFA the chicken was perfectly moist.
Spice (5 points): Shantel would call this a toss up, I would give the victory to CFA, since I'm writing the post, I'm calling it, CFA scores the points. Shantel liked the spiciness of the Popeye's best, I liked CFA better. However, CFA has spiciness in the breading and Popeye's just adds a spicy sauce to their regular chicken sandwich breast. For me, that is a deal breaker because it is not a proper spicy chicken sandwich. Even so, I prefer the spiciness of the CFA sandwich because I feel like it is slightly spicier, but then I get to dip it in the CFA sauce and that creates a perfect taste profile.
Breading (3 points): Shantel and Jenna voted for Popeye's here for their thick breading. But I don't love the breading so thick, but we'll give it to Popeye's.
Pickles (3 points): This one goes to Popeye's who have fancier pickles. I don't like pickle's, so I'm not swayed.
For me, I feel good when I go to Chick-Fil-A and the taste is amazing. I liked the Popeye's sandwich, but it is not fair for any sandwich to be compared to Chick-Fil-A.
Final Tally Overall:
Chick-Fil-a: 17
Popeye's: 13
Final Tally Sandwich only:
Chick-Fil-a: 10
Popeye's: 9
We had so much fun with the taste off! We can definitely agree that Dr. Pepper is the soda of choice to go with it.
After the taste off we decided we really wanted to try a couple of competitors (Slim Chickens and Super Chix) to see if they could compare.
Slim Chicken's had some good dipping sauce, but was not particularly memorable or special. Super Chix Nashville hot chicken sandwich was a little too spicy. I'd still rather take the CFA any time and Shantel would rather have a Popeye's sandwich.
Either way, it made for some great date nights and we learned one thing for sure - we love spicy chicken.